As the holiday season begins, our
television stations, movie theaters and sales racks are filled with
touching holiday stories that melt the heart, and sometimes, make you
think about how you could be a better person.
Already, we're watched our umpteenth
rerun of “The Wizard of Oz,” “Charlie Brown's Christmas,”
“The Christmas Carol,” and maybe even some of the crazy comedies,
“Home Alone,” and “A Nightmare Before Christmas.”
Adults may be watching “The
Preacher's Wife,” with Cary Grant as the preacher. I have to
admit, I really enjoyed the version with Whitney Houston as the
preacher's wife.
All of these movies have a redeeming
message – even if there may be a gory moment or two in the story
line.
Which brings me to question the current
rage for “Hunger Games” books and movies. I've listened to my
students describe their class-assigned “Hunger Games” often
enough to NOT want to read the book or watch the movie. Students
recount their memories as we walk from building to building, but, I
hear no redeeming value or myth in this series of young adult
fiction. All I hear is: do whatever you have to do to survive.
Kill or be killed. Trust no one.
For some reason, the third movie of the
“Hunger Games” series was released last weekend – not what you
would expect for the start of our Thanksgiving and Christmas holiday
seasons. But, how is it possible, at a time when our purpose should
be the teaching of human values that helped our first American
settlers to survive, that “Hunger Games” grossed the highest
earnings of the year?
I finally decided to watch the movies,
read the books, and consult with colleagues to determine whether I
was too biased to make this claim. But, my colleagues agree with me:
“Hunger Games” has no socially redeeming value. The novels and
the screenplays are franchises, business entertainment ventures
designed to be as depraved as necessary to rake in profits.
“May the odds be always in your
favor,” that cynical phrase spoken to young teens who are forced to
kill each other if they want to survive, truly epitomizes the
“dystopian” future depicted in this story. The story teaches our
youth that cooperation, support, interdependence will get you killed.
Social manipulation, cunning, ruthlessness, and the willingness to
kill first will keep you alive. Worst of all, the books teach our
youth that this is the only way you can survive.
The American Thanksgiving legends that
we celebrated this week are the healthiest antidote to this sick
futuristic vision. Europeans would never have survived their first
years in America if they took up the “Hunger Games” mentality.
I come from the state of Pennsylvania,
Where William Penn and his wife Hannah established one of the first
colonies, embracing the Quaker philosophy of brotherhood and
peace-making. We never see adequate portrayals, but, the first
Thanksgivings were celebrations with Native Americans who helped
Europeans to adapt to their wild, but harsh new surroundings.
As a Philadelphia native, I was raised
to believe that cooperation and interdependence are key to survival.
Our very own Benjamin Franklin established the nation's first
cooperative fire stations, libraries, hospitals, universities, post
offices and an insurance company. Ben Franklin not only helped birth
the United States of America by signing the Constitution – he
helped it survive by teaching us to cooperate, share, and distribute
burdens and risks in a way that ensures the survival of all who
strive.
These are the stories our children need
to be taught during our Thanksgiving holidays, and throughout the
year.
But, alas, I am told children do not
want to learn about their history. They want gory, futuristic
science fiction or dystopian fairy tales.
Really? Then why, when we watch
“Frozen,” do our kids watch with apt attention? Why, when the
nation is torn apart with racial strive, do our kids watch
“Hairspray” and lip-synch to the lyrics? Why, when we sing the
Chipmunks “Christmas Time is Here,” do the kids laugh with warmth
and the feeling of safety?
No one can force us to read the books
or watch the movies, thank goodness, because we do not live in the
totalitarian state depicted in “Hunger Games.” But, children
really are healthier when they are steered away from this sick,
anti-human philosophy of life towards stories that affirm humanity
despite its flaws. Because, when we learn how to live
cooperatively, despite our flaws, the odds are good that we will not
only survive, but we can all thrive together.
Speaking of flawed mythical characters,
have you seen “Fred Claus?” I can't imagine a better movie for
families who cope with sibling rivalry. Here's to your family
friendly viewing!